SB Transfer Station Part 1: The Trash Economy

Most of us spend a lot of time thinking about our stuff. We dream about the stuff we want. We work to earn money to buy stuff. We research the best stuff to get. We spend time shopping for stuff. We spend time and money to maintain our stuff. We then spend more money so we can store our stuff. We stress about how much stuff we have. Then we get rid of our stuff. Unfortunately we often haven’t thought a lot about what happens to our stuff when we are done with it.
The staff at the South Berwick Transfer Station spends a lot of time thinking of what happens to the steady stream of waste that the citizens of
After getting the full tour I came away understanding three things I didn’t know about the transfer station. First, and you probably know this if you’ve spent any time at the transfer station, almost everyone who comes to the transfer station has an opinion or a question about how the transfer station is run, a suggestion about what should be done, or some color commentary about the state of the town. I have new appreciation for how friendly and patient the staff is.
Second, I realized what a logistical challenge it is to funnel the steady flow of people and waste into the transfer station to make it easy and safe for citizens to navigate and to get all the waste to the right place at the transfer station. The staff is not only dealing with the waste, they are constantly answering questions, explaining policies, teaching about what goes where, monitoring and enforcing rules, and keeping an eye on safety of cars, adults, and children.
Mr Boucher described some of the ways the transfer station is trying to make the most of the market:
-The transfer station gets $1200 a ton for aluminum cans and they can ship out about two tons per month. They used to separate returnables but found that the cost of labor made it a loss—they can bring in more revenue mixing all the cans.
-The purchase of the plastic bailer opened up more markets for plastics since plastic recyclers will only take bailed product. Plastics brought in approximately $50,000 last year and Gary Boucher expects approximately $100,000 next year.
-Corrugated cardboard now brings in $124 a ton while a year ago it only brought in $40 a ton. The transfer station is trying to encourage more cardboard recycling to take advantage of its rising price. Mr. Boucher says they did research and found that clean pizza boxes are acceptable. Apparently
-The skyrocketing demand for metals from the Asian market has driven up the revenues the town can get from anything metal. Gary Boucher says even things like umbrellas or folding lawn chairs with metal parts can go in the metal bin. Metal brings in $180 a ton. Even power cords cut off of any appliance that is being discarded can be sold for the copper value.
-Shingles and roofing are separated from construction debris because they cost less to haul away as a separated commodity than the cost for mixed construction waste.
Gary Boucher also answered some frequently asked questions:
What is your take on the pay per throw plan adopted by the Town Council?
Pay-per-throw is an economic incentive for residents to reduce waste. Charging residents a fee for each bag of trash generated gives them incentive to discard less waste. Typical results are a significant increase in waste reduction and recycling. Pay-per-throw provides a continuing motivation to residents to reduce their expenses for trash services and gives the price signal to residents to decide on the actions they should take to dispose of less trash and increase recycling.
What advantages does it have over the present system?
Under the present system, no matter how much or how little residents use the service, they incur no financial consequence and reap no financial benefit. Residents typically respond to (apparently) free services by overusing them. Overuse of services results in unnecessarily large amounts of garbage with excessive costs for which residents must them pay. Therefore, waste reduction means lower tipping fees to MERC and increased recycling means higher revenues to the town to help cover operational costs.
Are
Residents are generally doing a good job recycling, and there’s always room for improvement. The greatest area needing attention is the “mixed paper” category. There is still a lot of mixed paper going into the hopper. Residents need to be further educated about what can and can’t be placed in the mixed paper bin. Getting residents to do more mixed paper recycling will further increase the town’s recycling efforts.
1) Proper separation of recyclables at each station is important. What good is going through the effort of recycling if items are not properly separated?
2) Don’t attempt to recycle glass and plastic containers with food residue. They’ll just be thrown away. Rinse out containers as best you can. Cleaning mayonnaise and peanut butter containers takes effort and energy to clean.
3) Most pizza boxes are recyclable corrugated. A little grease in the boxes is OK. However, many residents leave pieces of crust and pieces of pizza in them, along with the paper or cardboard liner inside the boxes. These should be removed before placing in the recycling area.
What was the rationale for the traffic pattern change at the station? How is it working?
Safety! Cars coming in the former entrance were entering the transfer station at 25+ mph right up to the hopper area. After posting a 5 mph sign, residents largely ignored it. There are a lot of kids at the transfer station that like to run around, especially on Saturday and Sunday. The new entrance forces residents to slow down around the disposal areas. It also helps keep the attendants that work each recycle station safer. Cars would come from every direction and attendants would always be on the lookout for weaving cars. Now cars are approaching from only one direction. This is especially important when attendants are operating equipment…vehicles are all flowing in one direction. I have had a lot of positive comments in regards to the new traffic pattern.
Why tags over stickers?
When stickers were issued, residents were asked to place them on the low part of their windshields. Many residents complied, while others didn’t, placing them wherever they wanted. Therefore you would find the stickers on every corner of the windshield (some up in the tinted area where an attendant can’t see them), on their side windows (where attendants couldn’t see them in the summer because windows were rolled down) and on the back window (with the hatchback window/door open while offloading waste). Attendants spent a lost of time asking residents “Where’s your sticker?” With tags, the permits are in the same place on every vehicle, every time.
Coming up next:
Part 2: The mystery of plastic recycling solved, mixed paper, fluorescent bulbs, and e-waste.
Part 3: Transfer Station policies and Gary Boucher’s tips and resources for reducing waste
June 2nd, 2008 at 12:35 pm
This is a great article, Molly. Thanks!
June 2nd, 2008 at 12:41 pm
My only concern about the pay per throw system is the lack of plastic recycling. Since only certain types of 1 & 2 plastics are accepted most still gets thrown away. Not to mention all the other plastics (4&5) that aren’t recycled at all anymore. I’ve begun noticing how much of these plastics end up in my garbage every week!
June 2nd, 2008 at 12:59 pm
I know what you mean Jim. I now have to pay close attention to the packaging when I purchase something. If its not recyclable, and I can’t reuse it somehow, I don’t usually end up buying it. I’ve started doing this now so that it will be habit by the time we have pay-per-throw. I don’t want to be caught off guard.
June 2nd, 2008 at 1:21 pm
Once again, though, those of us who already recycle thoughtfully, compost our vegetable leavings and leave a small garbage footprint get the short end of the stick. Why can’t a middle ground be reached? Why not supply one bag per household per week free of charge, then whoever uses more than that gets to pay? Apparently, per the article, it is not the USE of the services that is the issue, it is the OVERUSE. Let those who OVERUSE foot the bill. Just my opinion, please don’t anyone jump all over me.
June 2nd, 2008 at 1:39 pm
It’s revenue the Town wants; stuff of the tax rate.
June 2nd, 2008 at 2:05 pm
ladyjane has a great idea, issue residents a set amount of bags for the year then after that is used up we have to pay for more. It could work!
I also have a concern with the plastics recycling. Not just with the 4s and 5s that we don’t recycle but also with the 2s that I get asked to toss in the bin because they don’t bail well.
June 2nd, 2008 at 2:45 pm
Would single steam recycling take all these materials?
June 2nd, 2008 at 3:33 pm
According to the solid waste commitee presentation at one of the council meetings, I believe they would.
June 5th, 2008 at 8:52 pm
Uncle Gary is SUPER!!!! LOVE the picture!!
June 10th, 2008 at 3:40 pm
Molly I know you had this in the works for a while and thanks for your coverage; I look forward to the next installment.
1) My concern on a pay as you throw system is MORE litter – some folks will turn to illegal dumping rather then pay. I am also with ladyjane on the idea of an allocated amount of no charge dumping and then a fee beyond that. I would also favor annual amnesty days where folks can dispose of trash with no questions asked. Maybe this way when I go for a hike or a bike ride in the woods I’ll see fewer illegal dumpsites then I see today!
2) I am very disappointed that our town only takes # 1 and # 2 bottles and jugs. The science behind plastics is simple every # 1 and # 2 is recyclable with out regard to the shape it is. The chipper / shredder that grinds up that bailed plastic doesn’t mind salad green, or raspberry containers. Please understand that I know that other numbers like #7 or #5’s are not commonly recycled but we must do better with the basics.
Regarding the # 5 lots of folks buy Stonyfield Farm Yogurt – who chose #5 because MOST people don’t recycle and #5 plastic (Polypropylene) uses less material up front! Then they took it one step further you can send your clean Stonyfiled containers back to them and they make sure it gets recycled. From there the # 5 go to a company in Mass (Recycline) that makes them in to toothbrushes and razor handles! (http://www.stonyfield.com/SpecialOffers/Recycline.cfm)
I’d be happy to help with a committee that ensures the transfer station is doing all that it can to recycle more!
June 10th, 2008 at 4:03 pm
PAYT ensures that everyone pays their fair share. If you are a conscientious recycler and composter, you will pay far less than someone who is not. It still costs money to throw our whatever little someone may throw out, but this system virtually insures equity.
June 15th, 2008 at 2:33 pm
I have learned a lot about the recycling process as we have just started doing it in Rochester, N.H. I have been doing it for 2 years. Mr. Boucher certainly knows his stuff.
July 25th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
Molly -
I know that you had planned other installments in the story of our trash any progress on those ?
If people are interested in another view of our habits as consumers and trash makers please take a look at http://www.storyofstuff.com/
JB
July 26th, 2008 at 11:46 am
single stream is the answer.send it all to eco-maine in one truck,they sort it and recycle it! check out their website at eco-maine.com. it is very informative. the transfer station could be slimmed down to just a few men and then you would see a big savings across the board.i know the solid waste group in town did take a tour at the facility and were very impressed by it..just think about it